Lessons from Edward Snowden
Beware Turnkey Tyranny
We Live Naked Before Power
Originally posted on 10/26/2019 at the Bracing Views WordPress Site
Edward Snowden recently talked to Joe Rogan for nearly three hours. Snowden has a book out (“Permanent Record“) about his life and his decision to become a whistleblower who exposed lies and crimes by the U.S. national security state. As I watched Snowden’s interview, I jotted down notes and thoughts I had. (The interview itself has more than seven million views [now 38 million] on YouTube and rising, which is great to see.)
The term in my title, “turnkey tyranny,” is taken from the interview.
My intent here is not to summarize Snowden’s entire interview. I want to focus on some points he made that I found especially revealing, pertinent, and insightful.
Without further ado, here are 12 points I took from this interview:
1. People who reach the highest levels of government do so by being risk-averse. Their goal is never to screw-up in a major way. This mentality breeds cautiousness, mediocrity, and buck-passing. (I saw the same in my 20 years in the U.S. military.)
2. The American people are no longer partners of government. We are subjects. Our rights are routinely violated even as we become accustomed (or largely oblivious) to a form of turnkey tyranny.
3. Intelligence agencies in the U.S. used 9/11 to enlarge their power. They argued that 9/11 happened because there were “too many restrictions” on them. This led to the PATRIOT Act and unconstitutional global mass surveillance, disguised as the price of being kept “safe” from terrorism. Simultaneously, America’s 17 intelligence agencies wanted most of all not to be blamed for 9/11. They wanted to ensure the buck stopped nowhere. This was a goal they achieved.
4. Every persuasive lie has a kernel of truth. Terrorism does exist — that’s the kernel of truth. Illegal mass surveillance, facilitated by nearly unlimited government power, in the cause of “keeping us safe” is the persuasive lie.
5. The government uses classification (“Top Secret” and so on) primarily to hide things from the American people, who have no “need to know” in the view of government officials. Secrecy becomes a cloak for illegality. Government becomes unaccountable; the people don’t know, therefore we are powerless to rein in government excesses or to prosecute for abuses of power.
6. Fear is the mind-killer (my expression here, quoting Frank Herbert’s Dune). Snowden spoke much about the use of fear by the government, using expressions like “they’ll be blood on your hands” and “think of the children.” Fear is the way to cloud people’s minds. As Snowden put it, you lose the ability to act because you are afraid.
7. What is true patriotism? For Snowden, it’s about a constant effort to do good for the people. It’s not loyalty to government. Loyalty, Snowden notes, is only good in the service of something good.
8. National security and public safety are not synonymous. In fact, in the name of national security, our rights are being violated. We are “sweeping up the broken glass of our lost rights” in today’s world of global mass surveillance, Snowden noted.
9. We live naked before power. Companies like Facebook and Google, together with the U.S. government, know everything about us; we know little about them. It’s supposed to be the reverse (at least in a democracy).
10. “The system is built on lies.” James Clapper, the director of national intelligence, lies under oath before Congress. And there are no consequences. He goes unpunished.
11. We own less and less of our own data. Data increasingly belongs to corporations and the government. It’s become a commodity. Which means we are the commodity. We are being exploited and manipulated, we are being sold, and it’s all legal, because the powerful make the policies and the laws, and they are unaccountable to the people.
12. Don’t wait for a hero to save you. What matters is heroic decisions. You are never more than one decision away from making the world a better place.
In 2013, Edward Snowden made a heroic decision to reveal illegal mass surveillance by the U.S. government, among other governmental crimes. He has made the world a better place but as he himself knows, the fight has only just begun against turnkey tyranny.
Bill, thanks for re-posting this article.
We are given only so many warnings about what the owners are implementing.
Since the original post, we've seen how dissent and truth seeking is crushed - who can forget the "I am the science" and the banning of counter arguments during COVID? The agreement of '50 intelligence officials" that Hunter's laptop was a disinformation plot (even though it wasn't). The attempted assassination of a former President that has all but disappeared from the news. How the country, led by an obviously senile President, is stumbling into two major wars without any debate.
We've already seen people in Britain arrested for only publishing opinions on social media. Is there any doubt that such criminalization will work its way over here - under the guise of some future "national emergency"?
We owe people like Edward Snowden, John Kiriakou, Chelsea Manning, Julian Assange, and many others an incalculable debt. But I fear we may not be able to do so much longer.
Love this post. Edward Snowden is a true American patriot in every real sense of the word. Just like Daniel Ellsberg and Chelsea Manning, etc. Julian Assange, while not American, is also among the true patriots for exposing lies, hypocrisy and illegal US government actions around the globe. The US National Security State operates on the "do as we say, not as we do" principle. As such, it is a global outlaw and the cause of horrendous suffering and devastation. Edward Snowden pulled back the curtain to give us a glimpse into the pernicious apparatus that does everything possible to hide its crimes.