63 Comments

On 9/8, I submitted the following letter to the New York Times. The NYT rejected it.

In a recent op-ed, Representative Mike Turner called for the U.S. to “invest” in new nuclear weapons. He was wrong to do so.

Firstly, the U.S. and Russia together already possess more than ten thousand nuclear warheads, enough to destroy life on earth and several other earth-sized planets. We need desperately to divest from nuclear weapons, not “invest” in them.

Secondly, “investing” in a new nuclear triad will cost the U.S. taxpayer $2 trillion. The most likely return on “investment” is nuclear winter and mass death.

Thirdly, America’s current arsenal, especially the Navy’s Trident submarine force, is extremely potent, highly survivable, and more than sufficient to deter any enemy.

At the height of the Cold War, I served in Cheyenne Mountain. As a young Air Force lieutenant, I witnessed a simulated nuclear attack on the U.S. by the Soviet Union. Even on the primitive monitors we had back in 1986, seeing Soviet missile tracks terminating at American cities was unforgettable.

We must stop building genocidal nuclear weapons. We must instead renew international efforts and treaties to downsize these dreadful and dangerous arsenals. Spending yet more trillions on more world-shattering nukes is worse than a mistake—it’s a crime against humanity.

Expand full comment

They've never published any of my letters, either, Bill. And they reject my comments from time to time, as well, especially when I'm critical of NYT editorial policy. ; )

Doesn't detract from the relevance and the truth of your statements!

Expand full comment

It seems well-reasoned. I can see why they wouldn't publish it. No sense in giving space to the other side of the discussion.

Expand full comment

Your experience supports my view that the slogan of the NYT is actually "all the news that's fit to wrap fish."

Expand full comment

"All the news that fits our views".

Expand full comment

The New York Slimes.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Sep 27Edited
Comment removed
Expand full comment

I'd guess you were banned because of the Neo-Nazi reference. You're not supposed to say that, Ray.

Expand full comment

Yet Western Media were reporting on Ukraine's Nazi's before Russia invaded - the hypocrisy.

Expand full comment

One should not forget that the same „gang“ that gave the world the Middle East catastrophe are also involved in the Ukraine/Russia (US/Russia) war. The triumphalist mindset running the foreign affairs of this country doesn’t or can’t understand how „others“ perceive America. Yesterday I received from Germany a copy of a book I read more than ten years ago and lost. It is a book by the late independent German scholar Karlheinz Deschner who spent his life researching and writing on various topics. I own a number of his books which unfortunately are not available in English translation. The book I received yesterday is a critical history of the USA. The title of the book is quite thought provoking for anyone who knows a little bit about ancient Middle East history and religion. DER MOLOCH - Eine kritische Geschichte der USA, 1992. The Canaanite (also Carthaginian) god Moloch was worshipped by burning (sacrificing) of children. Deschner takes in America’s development from its beginning to the Gulf War of 1991. It is not a pleasant book to read and the author is well informed. It is not what is presented as American history from elementary school to college/university. The closest American equivalent is Howard Zinn‘s A PEOPLES HISTORY OF THE UNITED STATES. Maybe the time has come for Americans to realize that times have changed and that the „insular“ isolation that it has enjoyed for over two hundred years is over and that the bullying tactics it has used don’t work anymore. I think that the foreign policy planners need to look more seriously at Russia and what Russia is capable of. The Russians sacrificed about 27 million of citizens to defeat Hitler and they burned down Moscow to defeat Napoleon. Thy know their history and know sacrifice. Americans don’t know either. What they know is mostly exceptional myths. Bill, thank you for thoughtful rumination.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Karl.

Expand full comment

I live only 50 miles from Omaha/ Bellevue were NORAD is located. I don’t want me or my son and his children to be incinerated form American (capitalist) interests. I also don’t want them to grow up in a devastated country as I did. I am selfish.

Expand full comment

You are sane.

Expand full comment

I like to think so.

Expand full comment

You are NOT selfish, Karl

Expand full comment

Dennis, thank you. I tried to live my life accordingly.

Expand full comment

On the other hand if we were a bit more insular isolationist we wouldn't be so much of an internationalist bully. Just saying.

Expand full comment

Alex, my reference to “insular” was meant geographically. Two weak neighbors and two oceans.

Expand full comment

But "insular" also applies to the U.S. mindset, IMO. Such thinking is what has given rise to the prevalent national conviction of American exceptionalism, dating from the end of the 19th century. Especially obnoxious in the last 75 to 100 years.

Expand full comment

I read a reference to a Senator Hale from, I believe, New Hampshire, who claimed exceptionalism for the ISA on the Senate floor in the 1850s. In the 1820s the Monroe Doctrine was officially announced. And then there were the Puritan clergy who claimed a special „divine“ calling during the colonial era. The concept is part of the American historical psyche.

Expand full comment

Very good. Thanks.

Expand full comment

"Yet certain 'experts' seemingly want it to escalate to World War III with nukes."

I don't think anyone wants an escalation, and I do note your "seemingly" qualifier, Bill. But I think it's a matter of sheer hubris. The people making the policy decisions believe themselves to be the ones with a lock on infallible judgment. They're so sure of themselves, they don't see what they're doing as gambling, which is REALLY scary.

Expand full comment

High on their own supply--and they control the nukes. Yes, it's scary.

Expand full comment

I made reference to Doctor Strangelove yesterday - and by implication his mad partner, General Jack Ripper with his mine shaft gap. But even more than the theoreticians of the age of MAD - who spoke in terms of multiple layers of deterrence while having a first strike plan in reserve; we now have academics and military 'leaders' believing and advocating for the concept of winnable nuclear wars (basically escalate to de-escalate). And with the end-times fervor of some Christian and Israeli religious sects in positions of influence, we are in an extremely perilous time.

Expand full comment

Our species deserves extinction. Dogs and horses don’t.

Expand full comment

I'm coming to the same conclusion. Thru out evolution many species have falling into extinction due to lack of adapting to environmental and genetic change. I'm coming to the conclusion we may fall into the sinkhole of extinction as well. We need to control our fight or flight evolutionary instincts and start using our enhanced large brain power. Lets focus our (large) brain power on living another day not fighting our way to nuclear Armageddon

Expand full comment

Very WELL said, Jazzme. Thank You for sharing those thoughts and convictions.

Expand full comment

....or any other non-human creatures.

Expand full comment

Of course. But I spoke up for dogs and horses because they are the most domesticated.

Expand full comment

Personally I don't think our species deserves extinction. But we do deserve a lot better class of leaders.

Expand full comment

We have only misleaders. The real leaders are assassinated by “lone gunmen” (working for the CIA).

Expand full comment

Please point thou finger at self. We vote em in

Expand full comment

Not me. Not this crowd.

Expand full comment

Great blog today, Bill. What you do best my friend!

What a surprise your letter to the NY Slimes was rejected!

ALL my comments on New Zealand online newspaper sites disappear in 15-minutes!*

The Russia-Ukraine War...eeerm... SMO would have been over in a month if the Yanks had minded their own godamn business! And the Murican taxpayers way better off! Millions still alive!

On Feb. 24, 2022 what Putin said was Russia sought the "demilitarization and denazification" of Ukraine, and Russia had no plans to occupy Ukrainian land, and threatened severe consequences for any country that intervened. Putin announced that Russia was launching a "Special Military Operation " to defend the Russian-controlled territories in eastern Ukraine, the Donetsk Peoples Republic and Luhansk Peoples Republic Under Article 51 of The United Nations Charter

Of course, Western propogandists said he was full of shit. A known lair. And that Vladimir Putin, a heinous dictator, one morning over breakfast had decided to emulate Adolf Hitler and take over the World starting with invading his neighbor the Ukraine!

That was the headline in every MSM breaking news!

Here is what my favorite blogger James Howard Kunstler says what really happened

I think his explanation is the most accurate!

“What sounded like a great idea to Neo-cons in the United States - to use Ukraine as a bear trap - rather suddenly revealed Europe’s and America’s manifold bankruptcies and revolted the whole rest of the world outside of Western Civilization.

Imagine Mr. Zelensky’s predicament. Mighty America and redoubtable Europe conned the former comedian to thinking that if he went along with a genius scheme to ruin Russia and knock off Putin, his sad-sack country would be transformed into something like Ukro-Disneyworld, while he, Mr. Z, would be lionized and made rich beyond his wildest imaginings. His backup was the greatest hegemonic power the world has ever seen. What could go wrong?

The poor schlemiel fell for it. He let NATO (that is, the USA) set-up, equip, and train the largest army in Europe, including battalions of bad-ass, hard-core Ukro-Nazis who had previously been so useful in the American-sponsored 2014 Maidan “Colour Uprising.” Mr. Z followed the US State Department’s orders to rain down artillery on Russian-speakers who lived in his own eastern provinces. Killing 14,000 civilians. He formally applied for membership in the NATO club. His country received billions of US dollars without audit oversight, just screaming to be creamed off by Ukraine’s corrupt leadership."

*EDIT: Their new trick is to say someone has hacked your account to post misinformation. So, we must close your account....ggrrrhh!

Expand full comment

Plus Boris Johnson told Zelensky the West would keep him safe from the Azov nationalists in the capital. Otherwise we would leave him to the wolves. At that point Zelensky should have just left the country with his millions rather than be complicit in the destruction of Ukraine. IMHO

Expand full comment

Cheyenne Mountain. Too bad you couldn't have taken pictures and shown us taxpayers what we paid for (sarc). I guess that where Congress and the President will go if there is a nuclear war. It figures. In the Western canon the Government always survives even if the populace dies. In the book "Fail Safe" a computer error causes a group of U.S. bombers to be given the order to attack Moscow. In spite of best efforts by both sides one bomber gets through and nukes Moscow. As penance, the US agrees to nukes one of our cities, but the city chosen is NYC rather than Washington, D.C. as you might suspect it would be. The President endures suffering because his wife is shopping there but at least the government is safe. For some reason you never see "Fail Safe" on TV, even though the movie is highly rated. I wonder why that is??

Expand full comment

I just checked Amazon and Fail Safe is there for anyone interested, but I think you are referring to the movie not being on "broadcast" commercial TV?

Henry Fonda was such a solid President in the movie. Hey! What if we had had Henry Fonda for President rather than Ronald Reagan? As for losing the wife shopping...the end of capitalism! That's almost as scary as losing NYC. Seriously, can anyone imagine a movie of that kind being made today? And I use that word intentionally - too serious for today when we are all told when we purchase something: "enjoy!"

Expand full comment

Alex: I believe I heard "Fail Safe" was based on JFK, and his Wife shopping was Jackie. Not as successful as Dr. Strangelove, in the Box Office, but critically it was...! Very similar to Dr. Strangelove, so much so that I heard plaigiarism Lawsuits were filed back then.

Expand full comment

I wouldn't doubt it. Strangelove has moments of farce. Fail Safe doesn't. In the 2017 Putin Interviews Oliver Stone gets Putin to watch Strangelove. Then he gives him the DVD in the case. Except the case is empty. Putin opens it and says, humerously, "Typical American gift".

Expand full comment

Ha, ha, ha... Robert Kraft Owner of the NE New England Patriots NFL Football Team once let Putin try on one of his World Championship Rings when visiting the US Putin never gave it back thinking it was a "Gift" It was not Kraft said!!! True story.

Expand full comment

I remember that. I recall that Kraft basically said he's welcome to it. Big Power Politics. Out of my league. I don't have a Super Bowl ring in any case.

Expand full comment

Kraft that Fat-Ass Billionaire made Nice Rings more like a Sapphire & Diamond encrusted Ingot than Ring worth close to 6 Figures, or so...lol

Expand full comment

Back in the day our Big Oil company sent a company jet and an exec to the Soviet Union to do an oil deal. One of the pilots had his own calculator. He was told to keep it on the jet. Apparently they didn't want their own pilots getting jealous. Another time a college friend went to the SU as a high school student. He and a friend were admitted to an otherwise closed restaurant. The first thing the waiter did was offer to buy the shirt off his back. Tales from the USSR.

Expand full comment

Early this year, the members of the board of the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists kept the Doomsday Clock at 23:58:30, just 90 seconds to midnight where it was set the previous year. They haven't changed it yet, but given the current situation I would be inclined to advance the Doomsday Clock to 23:59:59, just about one second to midnight. https://wrknight.substack.com/p/235959

Expand full comment

Good podcast. Maybe someday they'll discuss this stuff in one of those "debates" pundits like to talk about. But I'm not holding my breath.

Expand full comment

It's established that WW3 was averted during the Cuban Missile Crisis when a Soviet officer kept a nuclear tipped torpedo from being launched though the command had been given to do so. It's worth noting that the one who issued the command to launch said essentially, "we will all die, but all of them will die with us"

This should be kept in mind when we hear of anyone saying what you wrote of being said, that the Russian bluff can be called because surely they won't commit suicide.

The critical thing about nuclear weapons is that they are the Great Leveler. It doesn't matter that one side has more warheads, more modern delivery vehicles, more megatons to throw. It means The End. When one has enjoyed unchallenged conventional power for a very long time it is easy to think that all will continue as it has to date. What empire didn't think this? At least historically, empires could convince themselves that in a disastrous war the tide could always turn. Sometimes that would happen but eventually, inevitably, it would not. Now we have no waiting, no tide that can turn, no ark that can ride out the flood of death.

We have a guarantee of a very quick ending with no winners, a loss to all humanity and without a single conventional battle needing to being fought between nuclear powers. But we still have fools who insist that one side can come out of a nuclear war better than the other. The thought that "we can prevail" dies hard in the powerful.

I am not the one to look to for hope. It will happen as surely as the lust for power / the practice of war is an integral part of being human. We have been extraordinarily lucky in the nuclear age, this does not seem to be appreciated, nor does it seem to bother the powerful that in the next and last episode of world war, we will take down most of the marvelous variety of life on Earth with us, which we are already destroying piecemeal, not even giving that a thought.

And whatever you or I think, it doesn't matter. Entire countries that never had a thought to get nuclear weapons will go down with those who took to them, the mighty US in the lead and still champion, as they say in sports.

Expand full comment

Yes , but a Champion of Death is no Champion...!

Expand full comment

When I did my "Penal Servitude" for SAC Strategic Air Command, USAF 73-77 I was Serving all 3 "Sky-Cop" (we carried 38 Revolvers & M-16's. 12 Gauge Shotguns too)-- areas of operation & security: Base Security, Convoys (Nuclear Weapons), Runways (the B-52's. "BUFFS"), and the Missile Fields (MInuteman MIRVS} It was interesting to say the least. I actually touched them the Warheads, and been in the Cockpits of B-52's. The Pilots some were younger than the Buffs that they flew! We patrolled the Flight Lines & Missile Fields too... I can't see how the Fixed Site ICBM's are still relevant myself. When in I was talking to one Major Missile Combat Crew member in our LCF (Launch Control Facility) below ground where they stayed. He had a Top Secret Clearance and said their missiles targeted China & the Soviet Union, and if we were ever defeated some were even targeted for the LCF's. LCC's, (Launch Control Centers) where we were on Duty in order to keep the weapons systems from going to the enemy. Not sure if he was pulling my leg on that last pt. Sometimes Warrant Officer's who needed Flight time to keep their flying pay would take us up in their Helicopters to check the Missile Sites too. "Peace Is Our Profession" Our Motto.... With regards to the NYT I hope you cancelled your Subscription. :/ :o) What I remember most was our returning from Vietnam "Sky Cops" They were Untouchable-- still got to wear their "Jungle Boots" "Jungle Fatigues" & Berets even though they were now back in the World as "Shorttimers" lol Always Chirping Short, short, short on their Radio's. Telling us all about the Re-up Birds & Fuck -U Lizards in SE Asia!

Expand full comment

If they show Zelensky autographing a nuclear warhead then I'll know it's time to panic.

Expand full comment

I recall seeing blue USAF vans driving out to the Titan sites around Tucson (1970-73), perhaps they were doing what you did starting in '73 or maybe it was simply shift changing. Your comment about the targets makes me wonder who are the people deciding these things? In the Titan control room I believe there were two officers each armed and sitting beyond reach but within full sight of each other. They were to simultaneously turn keys, one for each, to enable a launch so that a "madman" alone could not cause a launch.

But here is the part I find most interesting, if one of them refused to do the job, the other was authorized to shoot to kill. Where is insanity in this scenario? Is the man insane who suddenly thinks he cannot kill hundreds of thousands of fellow human beings and refuses to do it, or is the man insane who will kill his fellow man for refusing mass murder? The answer is easily given by officialdom - the man who refuses mass murder is insane and must fear his own death to insure he does his job.

Expand full comment

Clif : Yes this was the SAC "2-Man Policy", and that was true! I was in Minuteman Missiles not Titans they were an older ICBM Vehicle though when I was Appointed a City Firefighter I found a brother Firefighter who also worked Titans in the Mid-West and we commiserated. Our Un-Official Motto in SAC was: "To Err is Human To Forgive is Not SAC Policy" lols Our Missile Combat Crew was also 2 Missileers carrying snub- nosed 38 Revolvers. We worked Top-Side in the LCF, they were subterranean in the LCC (Launch Control Center), and we stayed in the Field (of Missiles) for 3 days straight when On-Duty!

Expand full comment

I worked for Radio Shack at the time and the manager of the store was a former Titan crew member. A more meek and mild and pleasant a guy nobody could hope to find, but willing to turn the key.

Expand full comment

Yes.., Duty, Honor, Country..!

Expand full comment

For the first time in history, on 26 September, 3 hypersonic missiles were allegedly fired at 1 target. Russia's Kinzhals were targeting an alleged F-16 bunker at an airfield in Starokostiantyniv. There's no confirmation of success, but 4 more Kinzhals hit targets in the same area the following day. That $70 million missile cost shows Russia's determination to prevent an escalation in the war i.e., to prevent long-range Western missiles being fired at it. It doubles as warning, in tandem with the recent change in its nuclear response rules, that it can strike Europe. Dangerous times. The difference in brinkmanship and idiocy is result.

Expand full comment

Sending F16's is the craziest idea. Russia rules the sky and neophyte Ukrainian pilots going up in a few F16's would quickly result in no F16's. Some experienced Western pilots could take them up, but that would just sacrifice them, too. I propose sending Victoria Nuland up in one and Hillary in another as they laid the groundwork for this insanity.

Expand full comment

I like your choice of pilots.

Expand full comment

RFK Jr will be speaking in Washington DC this Sunday 29th at the Rescue the Republic Rally along with Russel Brand, Bret Weinstein, Jimmy Dore, Tulsi Gabbard, Pierre Kory, Del Bigtree, and a whole host of other freedom-fighting all-stars.

To see the full lineup and other details, please visit the following link: https://jointheresistance.org/ 4

Expand full comment

How did Dr Oppenheimer put it?

"Now I Am Become Death, the Destroyer of Worlds."

The Story of that Infamous Quote : https://www.wired.com/story/manhattan-project-robert-oppenheimer/ .

Expand full comment

I'm unable to find my present location listed in General Turgidsen's book of "World Targets in Mega-Deaths," but I'm not sleeping any better for it.

Expand full comment